Has Grandpa Lost His Marbles or Am I Losing Mine?

Q. My father, Jim, has been a big help to our family. He picks up our daughter, Sophie, from preschool every day and watches her while my husband and I are working, which we are very grateful for. Lately, however, he has been forgetting a lot of important things. Last week, he forgot to take Sophie’s lunch from the refrigerator and she ended up not having a lunch to eat at school after I reminded him three times. A couple of days ago, he went to pick Sophie up at school when I was supposed to do so, and I was upset when I saw my daughter wasn’t there at pick-up and ready for her doctor’s appointment. He even once sent her to school with tights and a top and forgot to put on her skirt. I was mortified when the teacher called me at work.

I have also noticed things have changed when I talk to him. He forgets a lot of names of things and important details. I once brought it up with him and he insisted that he was okay, and changed the subject. My mother, Joan, acknowledges that he also has been forgetting to pay bills lately, but is convinced that forgetting things is a normal part of aging and that maybe he isn’t getting enough sleep. I wish that I could get them both on board with my concerns about dad, if they are indeed valid.

Again, we are so appreciative for all the help, and I know that he loves his granddaughter, but I am concerned for my father and for Sophie in his care. Am I right to be concerned? If so, how do I broach this difficult topic with him and my mother again without hurting his feelings or facing his denial and refusal to get checked out by a doctor? Also, from a legal perspective, what do we do if we find out that he is in the early stages of Alzheimer’s or another form of dementia?

A. Five million Americans have Alzheimer’s disease, with a new diagnosis being made every seventy-two seconds, with millions more at risk. Although experts agree that early diagnosis and treatment are essential, some people with memory loss, such as your father, often don’t think that there is a problem and are unwilling to get screened.

One of the hardest conversations an adult child can have with an aging parent is about their concerns regarding their aging parents’ health, safety and/or finances.  Because of the difficulty of such topics, many families don’t have the conversation until it is too late.

Whether it’s caring for your daughter or forgetting to pay the bills, making mistakes while doing something one has done for many years is alarming, and you have a right to be concerned. However, it sounds like getting your father to the doctor might be tricky, and getting your mother on board may be a challenge, as well. Below are some suggestions for when you do attempt to have the conversation once again with your family:

  • Be direct with your parents about the issues you observe with your father. It is possible to be direct, yet respectful.
  • Approach your parents with your concerns about your father, stressing your intent to help, not to criticize. 
  • Avoid ganging up on them or pushing them into a corner. Be casual, open-minded, but not too invested or persistent.
  • If your father currently trusts a relative, friend, or clergy person as someone who has all the right answers, ask this person to casually support your idea.
  • Don’t focus on your father’s deficits, but rather on what can be gained by early treatment.
  • Make it your issue rather than your parents. Tell them that you would rest easier knowing that your father has the most up-to-date information about how to retain his memory, function and quality of life.
  • If your parents react negatively, drop it and try again. If they still refuse, just tell them it’s so hard to get an appointment with the doctor, and that you scheduled an appointment far in advance just in case.
  •  If they react with anger, just say “I’m sorry – I mean well.” Suggest you go with them to the doctor and then go out to lunch or to some activity they really enjoy.

Once your family is agreeable, a good evaluation from a trusted doctor will give your family some answers about your father. Please read our blog post about the SAGE Test, a test that your father can complete at home and bring to his primary care doctor, who will determine if further evaluation is needed.

Once you are at the physician’s office, be sure to stay with your dad (and mom, if she comes too) for the examination. That way you can hear the doctor’s recommendations and get a first-hand report. If you stay in the waiting room, your dad may come out and report that all is well! He may not have understood the doctor’s message or have forgotten key parts of the conversation. Hopefully the physician will discover a reversible issue, such as a B-12 deficiency, a medication issue, or depression, and not dementia!

The Alzheimer’s Association has many suggestions about how to prepare for the evaluation and how to get the most out of your time with the doctor or evaluation team. You’ll be surprised by the number of successful but quite different approaches families use to insure timely evaluation of changes in memory and thinking.

When it comes to legal planning, if your father is diagnosed with Alzheimer’s or another dementia, creating a plan for your father’s future in the early stage of the disease can be empowering and can ensure that his wishes are met. The sooner he establishes his legal plans, the better prepared your family will be.

Our firm, the Fairfax and Fredericksburg Elder Law Firm of Evan H. Farr, P.C. ( is dedicated to helping protect seniors and individuals with Alzheimer’s and other types of dementia by preserving dignity, quality of life, and financial security. With proper planning, when the time comes for your father to enter a nursing home, your family can retain all of the assets and most or all of the income while Medicaid takes care of the nursing home.  Proper planning also helps to ensure that your mother will be able to maintain her dignity and standard of living.  Read more about the services we offer to help families in similar situations, then call us at 703-691-1888 in Fairfax or 540-479-1435 in Fredericksburg to make an appointment for an introductory consultation.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
About Evan H Farr, CELA, CAP

Evan H. Farr is a 4-time Best-Selling author in the field of Elder Law and Estate Planning. In addition to being one of approximately 500 Certified Elder Law Attorneys in the Country, Evan is one of approximately 100 members of the Council of Advanced Practitioners of the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys and is a Charter Member of the Academy of Special Needs Planners.

Leave a comment

Thank you for your upload